Hanging your lutes to the wind

A few years ago the conservator of the Antwerp Vleeshuis museum showed me this picture.

Calvinistisch oproer in Antwerpen bedwongen, 1567

It’s named “The Calvinist uproar restrained”, and was made by Frans Hogenberg between 1567 and 1570. This was the time of the 80-year war between Philip II of Spain and the Low Countries. Philip, the son of emperor Charles V, was a devout catholic. But in Germany the ideas of former monk Martin Luther (also an accomplished lute player) were rising.

Philip II

Philip on a 1/5 Philipsdaalder, struck in 1566

Unlike his father (who had grown up here), Philip was raised in Spain, under a very strict protocol. He didn’t have much sympathy for that little swamp in the north. Especially not when the people of that small province started to rebel against his reign. The Netherlands (which also contained Flanders) wanted autonomy and religious freedom. The rebels found an ideological justification in Protestantism, and especially the strict teachings of John Calvin of Geneva became highly popular.

Philip was highly opposed to protestants and started to prosecute them. But unlike what he had hoped, the religion grew in a high tempo. It was a combination of religious and political reveille. In 1566 the tension rose with an iconoclast fury. Groups of rebels went to the churches and destroyed their inventory. Statues and stained glass windows, were broken, paintings and liturgical clothes were burned. Gold and silver was stolen and

The Duke of Alva, engraving by Frans Hogenberg

The Duke of Alva, engraving by Frans Hogenberg

monks, nuns and priests were beaten up and sometimes even murdered.  In reaction to this Philip send the Duke of Alva (the ‘Iron Duke’) to the Netherlands to restore the peace and punish those responsible. Alva’s ‘council of troubles’ would become know as the ‘council of blood’ because of the high number of executions they ordered.

The engraving shows one of the Calvinist uproars at the Antwerp Meir on march 14, 1567. This was calmed by major Anton Straelen. In some books we find it with the erroneous description that it is a depiction of the “Spanish Fury”. In november 1576 a group of mutinous Spanish soldiers started to loot in Antwerp. Three days they murdered, tortured, robbed and raped the people of the city. Hoogstraten also depicted this, but in a different set of engravings…

Spanish fury Spanish fury
The Spanish Fury – two pictures by Frans Hogenberg

Lutes on the flagpole

But why did I show you this picture and tell this story? Well, take a good look at the house in the lower left corner… From the top window hangs is a flagpole with three instruments. Two lutes and something that looks like a gamba (or guitar?).


So why would they hang a couple of lutes outside of te window? Especially in march, when the weather isn’t all too friendly in the Lowlands… Would this perhaps be the home of an instrument maker who hung them out to dry their lacquer? Or for the southern European practice of sunbathing instruments? Maybe, but we simply don’t know. But it’s still a rather nice and curious touch…

I simply had to try… but no real advantage here in the cold and rainy Netherlands…


This entry was posted in History, Nonsense, Research, Uncategorized, Workshop and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Hanging your lutes to the wind

  1. My wife says it is to tan them. She is a German Luthier. but it is just as wet and cloudy here as there so I dont know.


  2. Luca says:

    Reblogged this on Liuti and commented:
    A really really great post!


  3. Steve Spark says:

    Maybe advertising, for the illiterate a lot of businesses had early forms of logos.


  4. Daniel says:

    “Don’t kill me, I’m a luthier”?


  5. Richard Benecchi says:

    I think it may have been to show his wares. It was probably a good way to advertize, just so long as the instruments are high enough that nobody can swipe them!


  6. Martin Taylor says:

    I suspect exposure to UV light has the value. Violin makers may have been doing the same thing in Italy around the same time.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.